Example conversation
Example conversation: selling services from Poland to Spain
One question in Claude with VeriActa connected: whose VAT applies to software services sold from Poland to a Spanish company, and how the answer is cited.
Other languages:DeutschEspañolFrançaisPolski
Software services sold by a Polish VAT payer to a business in Spain are taxed in Spain, not in Poland: the place of supply is where the customer is established (art. 28b ust. 1 of the Polish VAT act), so the Polish invoice carries no Polish VAT and says “odwrotne obciążenie” (reverse charge), and the Spanish customer accounts for the VAT. Below is how that answer looks in an AI assistant with VeriActa connected, and what happens behind it.
The conversation is an illustration written from what the tools return, shortened for reading. It is not tax advice for a specific case.
The question
You: I run a small software company in Poland. We’re invoicing a company in Madrid for development work. Do we charge Polish VAT?
The answer, with its sources
Assistant: No Polish VAT. For services to a business customer, the place of supply is where the customer is established, here Spain, under art. 28b ust. 1 of the Polish VAT act (ustawa o podatku od towarów i usług, consolidated text in Dziennik Ustaw). The Spanish company accounts for the VAT in Spain under the reverse charge.
On the invoice: no Polish VAT rate, the words “odwrotne obciążenie” (art. 106e ust. 1 pkt 18), and both VAT numbers. You need to be registered for EU transactions (VAT-UE, art. 97 ust. 3 pkt 1) and report the sale in your recapitulative statement (art. 100 ust. 1 pkt 4). Before invoicing, it is good practice to check the customer’s EU VAT number in VIES.
Sources: art. 28b ust. 1, art. 106e ust. 1 pkt 18, art. 97 ust. 3 pkt 1 and art. 100 ust. 1 pkt 4 of the VAT act, in the version in force today, with links to the official text.
What happens behind the answer?
In this example the assistant does not answer from memory. It calls VeriActa first:
- A search in Polish law (
jurisdiction: "PL") for the place of supply of services to a business in another member state. VeriActa returns art. 28b ust. 1 with its full text, citation and link. - A lookup for the invoice, which returns art. 106e ust. 1 pkt 18 and the exact words the invoice must carry.
- A lookup for registration and reporting, which returns art. 97 ust. 3 pkt 1 (VAT-UE registration) and art. 100 ust. 1 pkt 4 (the recapitulative statement).
Each lookup returns the version in force on the day of the question, so a rule amended last month would show its new wording and an amendment due next month its date. Every legal statement in the answer maps to a provision a lookup returned; the VIES check is practical advice, not a quoted rule. If a statement had no provision behind it, the assistant would have nothing to cite, which is how invented article numbers get caught (why assistants invent them).
What about the Spanish side?
The Spanish customer’s obligations come from Spanish law, and Spain is live on VeriActa too. Ask about the Spanish side and the assistant looks it up in Spanish law from the BOE with jurisdiction: "ES", so the same question is answered from both sides, each from its own official source.
Official sources
- Ustawa o podatku od towarów i usług (the Polish VAT act, Dz.U. 2004 Nr 54 poz. 535, with its consolidated texts), ISAP
- VIES, the European Commission’s check of EU VAT numbers
Frequently asked questions
Does this apply to every service?
Art. 28b ust. 1 is the rule for business customers; real-estate services and a few others have their own, and the assistant looks up yours.
What if the customer in Spain is a consumer?
The rule for consumers applies; mention it and the assistant looks it up.
Can I see the provision myself?
Yes. Every provision the assistant cites comes with a link to the official text, so you can read it in full.